SciCheck Digest
Contrary to claims amplified by podcaster Bret Weinstein during an interview with Tucker Carlson, COVID-19 vaccines have saved millions of lives, not killed 17 million people worldwide. Weinstein also inaccurately characterized a proposed World Health Organization pandemic accord and other changes, claiming they aim to take away “personal and national sovereignty.”
Full Story
COVID-19 vaccines reduce the risk of severe COVID-19, including in children, and serious side effects are rare. Increasing evidence indicates they reduce the risk of long COVID, and they are estimated to have saved millions of lives.
Still, various people have persisted in making egregiously false claims about COVID-19 vaccines, blaming them for hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.S., or millions of deaths globally.
According to a survey conducted by the Annenberg Public Policy Center, FactCheck.org’s parent organization, over time more and more Americans have come to incorrectly believe that the COVID-19 vaccines have killed large numbers of people. In August 2023, for example, 34% of respondents said it was probably or definitely true that the COVID-19 vaccines had killed thousands of people in the U.S., up from 22% in June 2021.
Recently, podcaster and former biology professor Bret Weinstein — known for spreading COVID-19 misinformation — spread yet another falsehood about COVID-19 vaccine deaths.
“I saw a credible estimate of something like 17 million deaths globally from this technology,” Weinstein told Tucker Carlson on a web show published Jan. 5 on Carlson’s streaming platform. Carlson, ousted as a Fox News host in April 2023, has a history of spreading misinformation on diverse topics.
Weinstein had previously told Carlson in the same interview that he was “hesitant to say what I think the toll might be because this is not my area of expertise,” referring to the purported harms from the COVID-19 vaccines. However, the false claim about COVID-19 vaccine deaths has since spread widely on social media.
Weinstein said on X, formerly known as Twitter, that the 17 million deaths figure came from former physics professor Denis Rancourt. Fact-checkers have previously concluded that Rancourt’s conclusions are flawed because they rely on assumptions that spikes in deaths were caused by COVID-19 vaccines without showing evidence of this — and when COVID-19 itself is a clear contributor to excess deaths.
Some of the social media posts have also spread incorrect claims from the same interview about the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines for children. Weinstein claimed that “there’s never been any proper justification of administering it to healthy kids. … Healthy kids don’t die of COVID, and the shot doesn’t prevent you from catching or transmitting it.” COVID-19 has in fact killed some children without known underlying health conditions, not to mention the otherwise healthy children who have gotten very sick. The vaccines have been shown to reduce the risk of severe disease in children, which is the primary goal, as well as infection to some degree.
During the lengthy interview, Weinstein also spread misinformation about the World Health Organization, claiming that a pandemic accord and other changes are being discussed that would give the United Nations agency sweeping powers.
“I think it is fair to say that we are in the middle of a coup, that we are actually facing the elimination of our national and our personal sovereignty, and that that is the purpose of what is being constructed,” Weinstein said, referring to changes that he said nations could sign on to in May 2024. Weinstein’s false claims about WHO have also spread on social media.
WHO nations are working on putting together a pandemic accord, to be submitted at an annual assembly in May 2024. They will also discuss possible amendments to global health regulations. But as we have previously written, neither the amendments nor the accord, also sometimes referred to as a pandemic treaty, would affect national sovereignty.
The accord “is a generational agreement among countries to work in cooperation—not in competition—to face shared threats with a shared response,” according to an email sent to FactCheck.org by a WHO spokesperson. The spokesperson also affirmed, “No country will cede their sovereignty to WHO.”
COVID-19 Vaccines Did Not Kill 17 Million People
Claims about mass COVID-19 vaccine deaths are not plausible, given the existing data on vaccine safety, which do not show elevated mortality among vaccinated people.
Rancourt and other researchers posted the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines caused 17 million deaths on Sep. 17 in a report by the Canada-based group Correlation Research in the Public Interest, where Rancourt is a board member and associate researcher. The report is not published in a peer-reviewed journal.
The authors of the report gathered data from various sources on all-cause mortality in 17 countries in the Southern Hemisphere, baselessly attributing all spikes in deaths after the COVID-19 vaccines became available to the vaccines.
The authors then calculated the supposed rate of vaccine-related deaths, coming up with a bogus figure they dubbed the “vaccine-dose fatality rate.” They then used these figures to estimate global deaths from COVID-19 vaccines up through September 2023, based on the number of people vaccinated globally.
Rancourt subsequently made a similar claim on Nov. 18 at an event in Romania that also featured Weinstein as a speaker.
Rancourt’s report did not consider COVID-19 deaths. Jeffrey S. Morris, director of the division of biostatistics at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perelman School of Medicine, highlighted the omission in a tweet to Rancourt the day after the report’s release.
“Why do you completely ignore the fact that the excess deaths all over the world largely cluster in spikes that happen to correspond to spikes of confirmed Covid cases and Covid-attributed deaths?” he asked. “They don’t line up with strictness of Covid mitigation, and they don’t line up with vaccination rollouts (except in places when vaccination rollouts were done during massive Covid surges).”
Since the start of the pandemic, COVID-19 is estimated to have killed more than 1.1 million Americans. Worldwide, more than 7 million COVID-19 deaths have been reported to the WHO. But during a Jan. 12 press conference, WHO’s COVID-19 technical lead Maria Van Kerkhove emphasized that that tally is an undercount. “We know that that number is certainly higher,” she said, adding that the WHO expects the true number is “at least three times higher.”
Children Benefit From COVID-19 Vaccination
Weinstein’s comments about healthy children minimized the harms of COVID-19 and potential benefits of vaccination for this group.
First, while COVID-19 is usually mild in children, the disease has been a leading cause of death in children — a group in whom deaths are generally uncommon. Between August 2021 and July 2022, COVID-19 was the eighth most common cause of death and the most common cause of death from infectious or respiratory diseases in Americans ages 19 and younger, according to a 2023 paper published in JAMA Network Open.
It is not always possible to identify which children will get very sick from COVID-19. According to data from a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention presentation, about half of hospitalized American children who died of COVID-19 between January 2022 and June 2023 did not have underlying health conditions.
There has been some legitimate debate over whether all children need to get vaccinated against COVID-19 or get updated shots. Still, there is broad consensus that the benefits outweigh the risks, and many experts and groups, including the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics, recommend COVID-19 vaccination for all children 6 months of age or older, unless there is a contraindication.
Second, while the vaccines’ main purpose is to prevent serious disease, they have also been shown to reduce the risk of infection in the short term.
For instance, a paper published Jan. 9 in Annals of Internal Medicine evaluated the effectiveness of the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine, finding that a primary vaccine series reduced documented infections in children in the omicron era by around 74%. The vaccines also reduced cases of moderate or severe COVID-19 by around 76% and ICU admission by around 85%.
WHO Accord Will Not Affect National Sovereignty
Finally, Weinstein resurrected claims about the WHO pandemic accord, as well as amendments being made to global health regulations. He claimed, among other things, that the organization would be able to mandate what vaccines people would and would not receive and take away people’s rights to free speech.
For instance, Weinstein agreed when Carlson asked him if he was saying that “an international health organization could just end the first amendment in the United States” — an assertion that doesn’t have grounding in reality.
“What Weinstein is claiming is an even wilder, more extreme, version of the idea that the pandemic agreement is going to take away America’s sovereignty,” Lawrence Gostin, faculty director of Georgetown’s O’Neill Institute for National & Global Health Law, told us in an email. “These claims are entirely untrue.” Gostin, who is also director of the WHO Collaborating Center on National and Global Health Law, has been involved in drafting the new pandemic agreement.
Mandates in the accord are meant to govern international obligations, not set nations’ policies within their own borders, Gostin previously told us. This includes, for instance, obligating countries to share information on disease outbreaks with each other.
In response to Weinstein’s claims, Gostin affirmed that “the US constitution is the highest law of the land. No international treaty can override the provisions of our constitution.” He called it “false” and “legally impossible” that the WHO negotiations could “override the First Amendment” — both because the negotiations contain no provisions to do so and because any such attempts “would have no legal standing in the United States.”
He also said that the agreement would not mandate vaccinations, treatments or other public health measures. “The WHO has no power to force individuals or countries to do anything,” he said.
Editor’s note: SciCheck’s articles providing accurate health information and correcting health misinformation are made possible by a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The foundation has no control over FactCheck.org’s editorial decisions, and the views expressed in our articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the foundation.
Sources
Havers, Fiona P. et al. “COVID-19-Associated Hospitalizations Among Vaccinated and Unvaccinated Adults 18 Years or Older in 13 US States, January 2021 to April 2022.” JAMA Internal Medicine. 8 Sep 2022.
CDC. “COVID-19 Vaccine Effectiveness Update.” COVID Data Tracker. 31 Aug 2023.
Werkhoven, C. Henri van et al. “Early COVID-19 Vaccine Effectiveness of XBB.1.5 Vaccine against Hospitalisation and Admission to Intensive Care, the Netherlands, 9 October to 5 December 2023.” Eurosurveillance. Jan 2024.
Tartof, Sara Y. et al. “BNT162b2 XBB1.5-Adapted Vaccine and COVID-19 Hospital Admissions and Ambulatory Visits in US Adults.” medRxiv. 28 Dec 2023.
Wu, Qiong et al. “Real-World Effectiveness of BNT162b2 Against Infection and Severe Diseases in Children and Adolescents.” Annals of Internal Medicine. 9 Jan 2024.
“Safety of COVID-19 Vaccines.” CDC website. Updated 3 Nov 2023.
Soucheray, Stephanie. “More evidence vaccination reduces risk of long COVID.” CIDRAP. 12 Jan 2024.
Trang, Brittany. “Covid Vaccines Averted 3 Million Deaths in U.S., According to New Study.” STAT. 13 Dec 2022.
Van Beusekom, Mary. “Global COVID Vaccination Saved 2.4 Million Lives in First 8 Months, Study Estimates.” CIDRAP. 31 Oct 2023.
Yandell, Kate. “No Evidence Excess Deaths Linked to Vaccines, Contrary to Claims Online.” FactCheck.org. 17 Apr 2023.
Yandell, Kate. “COVID-19 Vaccines Save Lives, Are Not More Lethal Than COVID-19.” FactCheck.org. 6 Nov 2023.
McDonald, Jessica. “Flawed Analysis of New Zealand Data Doesn’t Show COVID-19 Vaccines Killed Millions.” FactCheck.org. 15 Dec 2023.
“Annenberg Science and Public Health (ASAPH) Panel, August 9-15, 2023.” Annenberg Public Policy Center of the University of Pennsylvania website. 12 Oct 2023.
Effinger, Anthony. “A Progressive Biologist From Portland Is One of the Nation’s Leading Advocates for Ivermectin.” Willamette Week. 15 Sep 2021.
Effinger, Anthony. “Local COVID Vaccine Skeptic and Ivermectin Fan Bret Weinstein Hosts Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Podcast.” Willamette Week. 5 Jul 2023.
Kertscher, Tom. “No Sign That the COVID-19 Vaccines’ Spike Protein Is Toxic or ‘Cytotoxic.’” PolitiFact. 16 Jun 2021.
“The Tucker Carlson Encounter: Bret Weinstein.” Tucker Carlson Network. 5 Jan 2024.
Bauder, David. “Fox News Ousts Tucker Carlson, Its Most Popular Host.” AP News. 24 Apr. 2023.
“Person: Tucker Carlson.” FactCheck.org. Accessed 12 Jan 2024.
Amanda (@the_barefoot_truther). “😳 17 MILLION!!! …” Instagram. 9 Jan 2024.
Tiffany Marie Long (@tiffanythetruther). “Are they really still recommending these for healthy children!?” Instagram. 6 Jan 2024.
Gentry Gevers (@gentrygevers). “Holy cow.” Instagram. 8 Jan 2024.
Brittney Kara (@brittneykara). “We knew it was dangerous. …” Instagram. 8 Jan 2024.
Mega Garbaggio (@megagarbaggio). “A series of important clips on the corvib scandal.” Instagram. 8 Jan 2024.
Bret Weinstein (@BretWeinstein). “If you want to understand how 17 million global Covid vaccine deaths (to date) was calculated, see the @denisrancourt video in the quoted tweet.” X. 7 Jan 2024.
Payne, Ed. “Fact Check: COVID-19 Vaccines Did NOT Kill 17 Million People — Coronavirus Was Killer.” Lead Stories. 9 Jan 2024.
“Analysis Claiming to Find COVID-19 Vaccines Killed 17 Million People Is Highly Flawed, Doesn’t Account for COVID-19 Mortality Surges.” Health Feedback. 11 Oct 2023.
Funke, Daniel. “Report Falsely Claims Covid Vaccines Killed 17 Million Worldwide.” AFP Fact Check. 5 Oct. 2023. Updated 10 Oct 2023.
Wallace, Megan. “Evidence to Recommendations Framework: 2023 – 2024 (Monovalent, XBB Containing) COVID-19 Vaccine.” ACIP Meeting presentation. 12 Sep 2023.
Smith, Clare et al. “Deaths in Children and Young People in England after SARS-CoV-2 Infection during the First Pandemic Year.” Nature Medicine. 11 Nov 2021.
“Benefits of Getting A COVID-19 Vaccine.” CDC website. Updated 22 Sep 2023.
Freedom is a God given right (@chad.dbell). “FULL DYSTOPIAN: COMING SOON. This is just the beginning…they are converging and centralizing power to gain full control. …” 8 Jan 2024.
“Pandemic prevention, preparedness and response accord.” WHO website. 28 Jun 2023.
“International Health Regulations: amendments.” WHO website. 31 Mar 2023.
Jaramillo, Catalina. “‘WHO Has No Authority to Dictate U.S. Health Policy’.” FactCheck.org. 25 May 2022.
Jaramillo, Catalina. “WHO ‘Pandemic Treaty’ Draft Reaffirms Nations’ Sovereignty to Dictate Health Policy.” FactCheck.org. 2 Mar 2023.
WHO spokesperson. Email to FactCheck.org. 10 Jan 2024.
Rancourt, Denis G. et al. “COVID-19 vaccine-associated mortality in the Southern Hemisphere.” CORRELATION. 17 Sep 2023.
Prof Jeffrey S Morris (@jsm2334). “@denisrancourt Why do you completely ignore the fact that the excess deaths all over the world largely cluster in spikes that happen to correspond to spikes of confirmed Covid cases and Covid-attributed deaths? …” X. 18 Sep 2023.
COVID Data Tracker. “COVID-19 Update for the United States.” CDC website. Accessed 12 Jan 2024.
“WHO COVID-19 dashboard.” WHO website. Updated 31 Dec 2023.
“Co-circulation of COVID, flu and respiratory pathogens.” WHO press conference. 12 Jan 2024.
McDonald, Jessica. “A Guide to Pfizer/BioNTech’s Pediatric COVID-19 Vaccine for Kids 5-11]A Guide to Pfizer/BioNTech’s Pediatric COVID-19 Vaccine for Kids 5-11.” FactCheck.org. Updated 5 Oct 2023.
McDonald, Jessica. “A Guide to COVID-19 Vaccines for the Youngest Kids.” FactCheck.org. Updated 22 Sep 2023.
Flaxman, Seth et al. “Assessment of COVID-19 as the Underlying Cause of Death Among Children and Young People Aged 0 to 19 Years in the US.” JAMA Network Open. 30 Jan 2023.
Jaramillo, Catalina and Robertson, Lori. “Q&A on the Updated COVID-19 Vaccines.” FactCheck.org. Updated 5 Oct 2023.
“Vaccines for COVID-19.” CDC website. Updated 13 Jul 2023.
AAP Committee on Infectious Diseases. “COVID-19 Vaccines in Infants, Children, and Adolescents.” Pediatrics. 29 Aug 2022.
Gostin, Lawrence. Email to FactCheck.org. 10 Jan 2024.